Posted by Scream Guest on June 7, 2009 - 12:40am
The Death of the Book
The "Death of the Book" was an idea first proposed by German thinker Walter Benjamin in a podcast published on his blog in 1928. The original concept then got translated through the usual social-media outlets and eventually spawn a full-fledged meme in several peer-reviewed message boards. It is also the organizing principle for the upcoming Scream in High Park. It is one of those inarguable modern ideas, the kind of thing thoughtful young literary men like myself speak of at cocktail parties and force you to nod your head consideringly until we agree to go away.
Many factors have been fingered as responsible for this pending death, be they technological, economic, or social. I thought I'd take a second in this tense pre-festival leadup to go over some of the suspects.
1. The Internet
The internet is kind of big. It is also full of words. While most people (source uncited) feel that the internet has increased the AMOUNT of reading we do, there's a belief out there that it has hindered our vocabulary (ROFLMAO!) and made us oratorical morons who need to PUT THINGS INTO ALLCAPS to SHOW OTHERS THAT WE MEAN IT.
One specific book-assassin I investigated is called "Daily Lit". It can be found HERE. Daily Lit is a service that trawls all the good bits from the world of open-source literature, cuts it into music-video sized chunks, and delivers it piecemeal into an inbox of your choice. I tried it out and was really into it for, like, 1 day. Then I tried to cancel the service and was unsuccessful. After the 75th installment of Theory of the Leisure Class spewed, unwanted, into my hotmail account at the 10-week mark of the marathon, I was glad I did not go for my first choice, The Odyssey, which takes (I wish I was making this up) six months of daily installments to deliver.
Review, Daily Lit:
Murder Weapon of Choice:Spam
Books when Because: You can read the amount you want to read, and then put them down.
Consolation Prize: The lulz.
**
2. Telecommunications
You know what I'm talking about. Specifically, the iPhone, which has an "app" that you can "download" to let you "read" files called "texts". This would seem to be a powerful device, from the company that completely screwed the music industry comes something to completely screw the publishing industry. I didn't get to test this device, alas, as The Scream couldn't quite pony up the "buying me an iPod" money this year, with the recession and everything. But I did look at the commercial a few times, and was struck by how you have to virtually turn the pages, which seems like both an affectation and an example of pandering. Also, the iPhone suffers from having other apps available that completely murder reading "The Odyssey" when it comes to the immediate visceral experience. For example, you can apparently buy a device that sticks into the end of the iPod, then you blow on it and (I wish I was making this up) it becomes a woodwind instrument. Nobody reads books on these things. They may buy the app and then buy a few files, but I challenge anyone to read a novel more than 400 pages long on one of these devices.
Review, iPhone:
Murder Weapon of Choice: Choice. Also, the pending discovery that it causes brain cancer.
Book win Because: They don't ring and then make you talk to somebody.
Consolation Prize: Millions of dollars.
**
3. The Kindle
Do you remember this thing? In the period between Sarah Palin and Swine Flu, this was the thing every third news story was about. Apparently they're still around, and about to be given away for free somewhere. This piece of crap is the Segway of literary implements.
Review, The Kindle:
Murder Weapon of Choice: Amazon.com, sweet irony.
Books when Because: People actually use books.
Consolation Prize: For Amazon? Anything to distract from the wholesale dismissal of gay fiction.
**
4. The Monoculture
This is the other possible book-murderer in the room. And of the four, it is the slipperiest, the least suspected. It is the "Mrs. White, with the rope, in the conservatory" of possible suspects. But this is of course the real villian in the end, the mastermind. Whenever we hear good news in our book blogs and trade magazines it's about some individual author or some specific new style or scene, there's never any good news for reading as a whole. For example, is it really a boon for children's literature that the final Harry Potter book has sold (I wish I was making this up) 44 million copies? Those kids are all reading the EXACT SAME combination of words. How disappointing. What if 440 books sold 100,000 copies instead? This is why literary festivals are important. Democracy. They bring out the small and mix it with the big and everybody stands on their own merit, not the proximity of their book to the Dora the Explorer section of the Walmart Toys Department.
Review, The Monoculture:
Murder Weapon of Choice: Boredom and complacency and..um...I've forgotten the last one.
Books when Because: They are tenacious and hard to kill.
Consolation Prizes: Music, Public Art, Politics, Talk Radio, Architecture, Urbanism, Graphical Design, Spoken Word, etc.
-Jacob McArthur Mooney, 2009